Why I Say No to Fukubukuro — Japan’s “Lucky Bags”

Every December, shops all over Japan start announcing their Fukubukuro 「福袋」— better known in English as Lucky Bags or Happy Bags. If you’re new to the concept, these are mystery bags sold at a set price, usually packed with items worth much more than what you pay. For fans of certain brands, it’s basically a treasure hunt. People will line up early on January 1st or 2nd (depending on store schedules), sprint into the mall, and grab whatever bags they can — kind of like Japan’s version of Black Friday.

These days, a lot of stores let you pre-order online or even reserve in advance to avoid the chaotic New Year crowds. And it’s not just clothing brands — places like StarbucksLush, and tons of lifestyle shops release their own versions too.

Clothing lucky bags come in all types:

  • Some only tell you how many items you’ll get.
  • Some give hints like: “You’ll get a sweater, top, and dress.”
  • Some reveal one item (like a coat in your choice of color) while the rest stays a surprise.
  • Others simply list the total retail value.

And then there are my personal favorite types — the ones that basically act like a discounted set and show you exactly what’s inside.


My Early Lucky-Bag Era

When I first moved to Japan, I was obsessed with these bags. I bought so many in my first few years here because the deals were just that good. But over time… something became very obvious:

I wasn’t using most of what I got.

I’d keep a couple of cute pieces, and the rest would sit untouched in their packaging. I can’t even count how many cheap winter coats I ended up with — worn once, maybe twice, and then shoved into the back of my closet forever.


The Turning Point

My “aha moment” came in January 2016 with a lucky bag from my favorite brand, Noela. I remember being so excited when it arrived… only to open it and feel instant disappointment.
Every item inside was something I never would have picked for myself.

That was the first time I really thought,
“I just spent ¥11,000 (about $110 USD) and didn’t get a single wearable thing.”

It hit me that I could have used that same amount to buy one item I truly wanted — something I would actually wear again and again. And that was the beginning of the end of my lucky-bag era.


Why It Happens

Even if you genuinely like a brand, the reality is that many clothing lucky bags are filled with old inventory — items that didn’t sell throughout the year (or even from several years prior). It’s basically a fun, festive way for retailers to clear out dead stock.

Once I understood this, it all made sense.


Should You Buy Fukubukuro?

Honestly, it depends on your lifestyle and shopping habits.

Lucky bags can be great if:

  • you love surprises
  • you enjoy bargain hunting
  • you’re not picky about clothes
  • you don’t mind a gamble

But if you’re someone who prefers investing in fewer, higher-quality pieces — like I do — then lucky bags probably won’t bring you much joy in the long run.

If you do want to try them, my recommendation is:
choose bags that clearly list the contents so you know what you’re actually paying for.


Would you ever buy a fukubukuro? Or have you had a lucky-bag triumph (or disaster)? Tell me in the comments — I love hearing everyone’s New Year shopping stories!

*Revised November 2025 for Grammar and Context

2 thoughts on “Why I Say No to Fukubukuro — Japan’s “Lucky Bags”

  1. I totally agree with you. I also bought lucky bags for the first few years when I first came to Japan but everytime I got poorly made very ugly and plain clothes despite the brand usually having more interesting clothes but not for the lucky bags. Also the coat from a lucky bag started pilling like crazy after only wearing it once! Which was very shocking. So after that I stopped buying lucky bags. Another reason to avoid lucky bags is you cannot know what material the clothes are made of, and these days I have stopped buying polyester and synthetic fiber clothing, its bad for both the health and environment as plastic ends up piled in landfills! Lucky bags are a waste of money and a waste environmentally. Japan has great sales during January at clothing stores so it is better to get sales and pick out clothes you actually like and that way one can check to see what the material is made out of too to pick natural fiber stuff. I got some 100 percent cotton, linen and hemp clothes from sales this January to replace polyester stuff after I became aware about polyester and fast fashion a few months ago.

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.